NAIC’s LATF solicits feedback on options to address concerns related to AG 49-A
August 18, 2022
On August 15th, the NAIC’s Life Actuarial (A) Task Force (LATF) re-exposed for comment four options to address a concern raised by state insurance regulators regarding the use of illustrations for indexed universal life insurance (IUL) policies with volatility-controlled indexes that allow for crediting fixed bonuses under the policies. The four options include a brief revision to amend Actuarial Guideline (AG) 49-A with the possibility of opening up NAIC Life Insurance Illustrations Model Regulation (#582) to revision as well as a more extensive revision of AG 49-A. All were previously exposed by LATF’s Index Universal Life Illustration (A) Subgroup (the Subgroup) prior to the NAIC’s National Meeting in August for a shortened nine-day public comment period that ended on July 26, 2022.
The four options were developed in response to regulators’ concern expressed at the July 18th meeting of the Subgroup that insurer issuers of IUL policies using volatility-controlled indexes were able to illustrate those policies at higher rates of return than illustrations for IUL policies without volatility-controlled indexes because of fixed bonus features. In that regard, insurer issuers of IUL policies with volatility-controlled indexes would use cost savings attributable to the lower costs of options associated with hedging strategies for the volatility-controlled indexes to factor in fixed bonuses in IUL policy illustrations. The fixed bonuses allowed the insurers to illustrate their IUL policies using higher rates of return.
The four options originally exposed by the Subgroup and re-exposed by LATF for comment are summarized below.
- An attempt would be made to implement a “quick fix” to address the current concern with a brief revision to AG 49-A. Discussions would also occur with the NAIC’s Life Insurance and Annuities (A) Committee to address whether the Life Insurance Illustrations Model Regulation (#582) should be open for revisions to address any broader issues with life illustrations.
- No changes would be made to AG 49-A which would allow the current practice to continue.
- AG 49-A would be revised more extensively to address the current concern as well as any other identified concerns.
- A “hard cap” would be imposed on various IUL policy illustration metrics.
The comment period for submitting written comments to Scott O’Neal at the NAIC (soneal@naic.org) on the proposal ends on September 6th. For your reference, we have attached a link to LATF’s exposure of the proposal. IUL Subgroup Re-Exposure
We will continue monitor developments related to potential amendments to AG 49-A. If you have any questions regarding this development, please contact Steve Roth (202-383-0158), Tom Bisset (202-383-0118), Eric Arnold (202-383-0741) or Maureen Adolf (212-389-5028).
___________
If you have any questions about this legal alert, please feel free to contact any of the attorneys listed under Related People/Contributors or the Eversheds Sutherland attorney with whom you regularly work.
Key contacts
Eric A. Arnold
Partner
Washington, DC, United States
Thomas E. Bisset
Partner
Washington, DC, United States
Steve Herbert
Of Counsel
New York, United States
Stephen E. Roth
Partner
Washington, DC, United States
Ronald D. Coenen, Jr.
Partner
Washington, DC, United States
Dodie C. Kent
Partner
New York, United States
Scott H. Rothstein
Senior Counsel
New York, United States
Latest Insights
- legal updatesFTC and states file enforcement action against digital healthcare provider challenging adtech & subscription practices
- legal updatesHong Kong: Enacts biggest listing framework reforms to enhance global competitiveness
- legal updatesTechnology Law Shorts - July 2026
- legal updatesProposed revisions to the Agricultural Foreign Investment Disclosure Act: an overview
Latest News
- client newsEversheds Sutherland Advises Johnson Matthey on Acquisition of CORMETECH Inc.
- media mentionsNew FINRA Report Aims at Making Enforcement a Little Less Painful
- client newsEversheds Sutherland Advises Horace Mann on Transactions with Medical Mutual of Ohio
- client newsAdvising Johnson Matthey on completion of the sale of its Catalyst Technologies business to Honeywell
Latest Events
- virtual | September 10, 2026UAE - Employment law in the Dubai International Financial Centre
- in-person | September 10, 2026Managing AI use in the workplace: what every UK HR team needs to know
- in-person | September 17, 2026Basic foundations of US employment law
- in-person | September 23, 20262026 BDC Roundtable
legal updates
August 04, 2026
FTC and states file enforcement action against digital healthcare provider ...
legal updates
July 31, 2026
Hong Kong: Enacts biggest listing framework reforms to enhance global compe...
legal updates
July 30, 2026
Technology Law Shorts - July 2026
legal updates
July 28, 2026
Proposed revisions to the Agricultural Foreign Investment Disclosure Act: a...
client news
July 30, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland Advises Johnson Matthey on Acquisition of CORMETECH In...
media mentions
July 28, 2026
New FINRA Report Aims at Making Enforcement a Little Less Painful
client news
July 27, 2026
Eversheds Sutherland Advises Horace Mann on Transactions with Medical Mutua...
client news
July 24, 2026
Advising Johnson Matthey on completion of the sale of its Catalyst Technolo...
virtual
UAE - Employment law in the Dubai International Financial Centre
September 10, 2026
9.30am - 1.30pm (GMT)
Virtual
in-person
Managing AI use in the workplace: what every UK HR team needs to know
September 10, 2026
9.30am - 1.00pm (BST)
London, United Kingdom
in-person
Basic foundations of US employment law
September 17, 2026
9.30am - 4.30pm (GMT)
London, United Kingdom
in-person
2026 BDC Roundtable
September 23, 2026
Washington DC, United States